Songs and Mysteries

Today’s book review is Rhapsody by Elizabeth Haydon, the first book in the Symphony of Ages series. This was recommended to me by my friend and podcast co-host Jess and was a book club book over at the Mallorean Tavern. Before I get to the review, there is one thing I want to discuss. This author has disappeared.

It’s true, or at least mostly true. Jess knows more about this than I do, since she was following this series pretty closely. At the beginning (in 1999), Haydon was publishing one book per year, or sometimes every two years. In 2006, she published the first book in a new YA series, The Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme, but still continued to write the Symphony books. There are now six Symphony books and two Ven books (according to GoodReads), but nothing has come out now since 2008. I know five years isn’t a long time in publishing circles, but to go from one book per year to nothing? That’s a little strange.

Jess and I were concerned that perhaps Elizabeth Haydon had passed away. Her official website (which I never saw, but Jess says existed) is gone. There is a link to a website for her on her GoodReads page, but it only brings up her Wikipedia page, which doesn’t list anything other than her official bio. The only thing to be found is a discussion board posting on where someone says that she is still writing and still intending to finish both series. I have no idea who this person is or where they got their information, but there is a lot of people going back and forth on there as to whether the information is accurate.

A very strange story. I hope Elizabeth Haydon is well and knows that her fans love her and are concerned. It’s very odd for someone to just vanish like this.

RhapsodyAnyway, on to the review. Rhapsody is a strange book. It’s also a very looooong book. It begins with this fellow named Meridion, who is watching Time pass through a machine. He plucks out a young man named Gwydion and moves him backwards in time to a point over a thousand years prior. Gwydion meets a girl named Emily and the two instantly fall in love. Gwydion promises to marry Emily, but as soon as Gwydion is alone again, Meridion moves him back to his own time period. Gwydion is devastated, and we can assume Emily will be too once she finds out.

Cut to the story of Rhapsody, a young Lirin singer. She was once a prostitute and a former client is harassing her. As she is trying to escape from the police, she runs into two men. As a singer, she has the power to Name someone, which can change their nature. When she meets these two strange men, she hopes she can use them to help her. She calls one of them her brother and says his name is Achmed the Snake. And all at once, this becomes true. The man’s name changes and they both agree to help her, for reasons of their own.

Rhapsody learns that they are not men, but part human, part Bolg. We also learn that Achmed, who before was known only as “the Brother,” had once been enslaved to a powerful demon because that demon had his true name locked away. Rhapsody’s renaming has broken that bond, but Achmed and his companion, Grunthor, are still being hunted. When Rhapsody hears that they are going to the Great Tree, a powerful and revered place of the Lirin, she agrees to go with them in order to escape the man hunting her.

Once they get to the Tree, they are attacked on many sides. Achmed cuts into the tree and the three of them disappear into the roots. They spend a realy long time traveling through the root system of the Great Tree. A really, really, really long time. The story kind of drags a bit here, but there are some important things that happen as well. They find a sleeping dragon, which Rhapsody casts a spell on so that he will not wake. They also come to the center of the Earth, which is a huge ball of fire. They are able to pass through the fire, although they are all changed drastically. It takes a while for them to realize how much.

Eventually, they make it out of the tree and find out that 1500 years has passed. They meet many people who help them, and I won’t go into all of them here. To sum up part of the plot, Achmed wants to go and reclaim the kingdom of the Blog, which has been destroyed, and sets himself up as king. There is still a demon out there looking for him though. Rhapsody meets a young man named Ashe who is more than what he seems, yet is completely enthralled with Rhapsody. And at the very end of the story, we see Meridion again, still huddled over his Time Editing machine, only this time, the strand of time he’s looking at snaps in half.

For the most part, this book was a bit of a disappointment, which was sad because I really wanted to enjoy it more than I did. Parts of it went so slow, and that made it hard for me to keep up with some of the lesser characters. Because of that, I started to loose interest in parts of it. I was really intrigued by Meridion and what he’s doing, but it was also very confusing. There is also the possibility that since I had to read this so fast for the book club, I wasn’t able to really digest it. There were lots of things that were good about the book – I really like Rhapsody, Achmed and Grunthor (Grunthor especially). The mythology created was very interesting, especially with all the music combining with the magic. I might have to re-read this one at some point, but for right now, it was good and I enjoyed it, but I wasn’t over the moon about it.

Has anyone else read it? Or heard anything about Elizabeth Haydon?

Categories: Books I've Read

Tags: , , , ,

7 replies

  1. I so much enjoy your reviews and glad you enjoy the fantasy books. I would have given up long before it came to an end. You really capture the heart and soul of the characters and the plot. Thanks. See you soon.

  2. I so disagree!!! I hope you have reread at this point and read the next 5 books. These are the best books I have ever read, no other author has ever been able to capture the true fight in the assassin like Elizabeth can… Oh I am over the moon about these books… All 3 of my girls were names in part bc of these books and one is even named Elegy. Oh I hope you gave this book another chance and I hope more do, as it deserves the acclaim!!!

  3. Which parts did you find slow? The root? I’d love to hear back from you !

    • Hey Amber! Yes, the root was definitely part of it. They spent way too much time underground and not that much seemed to be happening. There were several parts that I did enjoy though! I’m sure it’s a very good book, it just wasn’t for me. And it might have been me anyway – sometimes I go through phases where I don’t want to read epic fantasy and just can’t get into it. That might have been the case, but I had to read it for the podcast that I co-host. I might give it another shot one of these days, once I get my TBR pile down to more manageable levels. 🙂

  4. You’ll be happy to know Elizabeth Hayden has resurfaced! The next book, The Merchant Emperor, just came out this month and the last book in the plot arc, Dirge, has at least been drafted. It sounds like the author went through a lot of terrible real life stuff the last few years. She references it in passing here:

    I have found most of these to be incredible books. She managed to make the mythology and the magic of the world feel intrinsic to the world, an inevitable part of it, pulling on a lot of real-world myths while making something that is also its own thing. And the characters are great. I agree the root is a bit of a slog, but it is for them too. As a writer, it is always hard to know how much to drag the reader through the long hard trials and tribulations of your characters; you don’t want to bore them, but nor do you want to trivialize what the characters are going through by summing up months or years of travel in a paragraph or a page. I thought she did reasonably well with that aspect, and great with much of the rest. Assassin King slowed down a little–it suffered from middle book syndrome in way earlier ones hadn’t. It felt like plots were advanced, but very little was achieved or resolved making it unfulfilling (especially with a multi-year wait for the next one); but now that the books are coming out again, I am very much looking forward to seeing how she ends it all.

    • I probably need to reread Rhapsody at some point – I may have just not been in the mood for something that long and drawn out. I had been reading a lot more faster paced books when this came up for review on the podcast that I co-host. I’m glad that Hayden reappeared and is writing again. I know several of her fans who were worried about her. 🙂

      Thanks for the news update!

  5. I agree that the Symphony of Ages is the best series written after Tolkein unless you are a death fan and then you should read GRRM. Elizabeth Haydon is an amazing writer, and her words sing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: